(Originally published March 6, 2023)
Hey, storyteller!
Imagine this: You sit down to work on the next part of your story and a cold knot forms in the pit of your stomach. You fidget, poising your hands on the keyboard, but every word you struggle to pull from your imagination fights you like a whale at the end of a fishing line. You glare at the blank page or next blank line as if it's withholding from you. The very secrets to survival, the survival of your future as a writer.
You've probably heard all the advice... "Establish a writing habit" or " Write every day"... advice I've often given students, but what if I told you following that advice might not be good for you? What if you should stop writing?
In this week's Writer Coaching session, we'll discuss what may be causing roadblocks to your writing or making you even dread trying, what to do about it, and yes, even when you may need to stop.
You will discover:
I Have a Gift for You!
First, I have a gift for you just for visiting my blog, my free workshop, 6 Essential Elements of a Powerful Story.
You started writing for a reason, or maybe several, but the one thing most writers have in common is the desire to impact readers with their. This 25-minute video workshop walks you through the main elements you need in order to make your story powerful. Plus, if you're reading this post because you're wondering whether you should even keep writing at all, this workshop may contain just that nugget of inspiration you need to jumpstart your creativity.
And be sure to read to the end of this post so you won't miss this week's Power-Up, a super practical action step you can use right now in the story you're working on, or to recharge those writing batteries.
3 Scenarios in Which We May Think We Need to Stop Writing
When writing becomes a dreaded exercise, or we feel like we'll never succeed at it, we're likely considering one of three possible scenarios. Either we need to stop writing for a while, we need to stop working on our current project and abandon it, or we need to stop trying to be a writer altogether.
Today, we'll examine each of these scenarios in terms of what might make us feel that way, why we shouldn't embrace that scenario and stop writing (or what we should do instead), and even times when we might be right and need to stop, on whatever level that might involve.
1. Stop Writing Temporarily
First, let's look at the possibility that we may need to stop writing for a while and take a break.
What makes us feel like taking a break?
This may occure if you feel stuck or are experiencing writer's block, or if this particular scene or part of the story is just boring, or maybe you just don't have any desire to write what comes next.
You may even procrastinate. If you find yourself doing the dishes or laundry or mowing the lawn instead of writing, it is a good indicator that you're dealing with this issue.
Or maybe you just have too much going on and don't have the time or brain space to devote to anything creative, let alone writing, which takes lots of energy and focus.
When you shouldn't take a break
Let's examine the reasons why it might not be in our best interest to stop writing and take a break, and what we should do instead.
if this is writer's block, depending on its cause, it may be better to just push through and keep writing than to stop, because stopping could make it worse.
Statement about list
If any of these fit your situation, you may just need to take some time to figure this out. Brainstorm ideas for how to write yourself out of the corner you're in. Maybe even talk with a writer friend and have that person help you brainstorm.
If you're just bored with this current section, you might need to replot or see if that scene could benefit from adding some sort of conflict, changing the location in which the scene takes place, or changing the viewpoint character for that scene. Put it in a different character's head.
I've had to do this on a couple of occasions, where the stakes didn't feel high enough or I was too close to that character for a scene and needed to get a little distance. So, I wrote it from the other character's perspective. On one occasion, I kept the scene in that other character's perspective, because the scene was more powerful that way. In the other instance, I actually revised the first version with the original viewpoint character, but writing it from the other person's perspective gave me insights I didn't have before, and it helped me to get out of the state of boredom with the scene.
You may also just need to skip ahead and write another scene that you find more interesting. Maybe the one you had planned to write is sort of a transitional scene between two more exciting ones. If you skip to a more interesting scene, you may be able to come back and write this transitional one at a later time.
Or try plotting what comes next. Even if you're a discovery writer, look at what you have so far and brainstorm ideas for what could happen after this scene. That might make you more enthused about writing it.
If you’re finding the story as a whole is boring, you may need to shift gears and work on something completely different. Start a brand new story or edit a different project that you've written already. Or go back and edit the beginning of this one. If you have another project that's vastly different from this one, with characters who are nothing like the ones in the current story, getting into their heads for a bit might help you jumpstart your creativity.
Sometimes, even if you’re finding a scene boring or just having an off day as far as writing goes, write anyway. Even if it turns out terrible, which many of our first drafts do, you can go back and fix it later. Plus, tomorrow, if you feel better or you're in a better mood, when you look back at the scene, you might find that it's not as bad as you thought it was.
Even if you did toss out the entire scene, nothing is wasted. If you go ahead and write it anyway, you're flushing out of your system the bad ideas. When we brainstorm, often the first few ideas that we come up with are not so great, or maybe they're cliche. We have to write those down before we can get to the interesting and good ideas. The same can be true for writing. If you're in a slump, go ahead and write the scene anyway. You'll at least flush out what doesn't work, and then if you rewrite it from scratch or revise it, better ideas will come to the surface.
The reason I'm advising you to keep writing even if you're stuck or just don't feel like it, is because once we stop writing, we lose momentum. If you stop for more than a day or two, it can be harder and harder to get back into the flow state or into the “zone.”
Even if I write every day, I write more slowly at first, and then I speed up and really get into the zone during the middle of that writing time. As I get tired, I'll slow down again. So, if it's that difficult to get started, even when you're writing every day, imagine if you take a week or a month off.
However, if you do take a break, don't let fear of that happening deter you from getting back into it.
When SHOULD you take a break?
Sometimes, unexpected life events occur that demand our complete time and attention. Maybe you or someone you love is going through an illness. I don't know about you, but when I'm really feeling lousy, it's hard to be creative. You might not even have the energy to sit at your computer or to devote to figuring out new ideas for a story. Creativity takes a lot of energy. It's surprising, in fact, how much.
If a loved one is going through an illness, you may be the caregiver for that person, and that can demand a lot of your time. Also, you may be stressed because you're worried about this person and whether they're making progress in getting better. You certainly don't want to be working on a story when your entire focus is consumed by concern for someone you love. That's okay. Take a break and get back to the writing later.
Other life events that can derail us can include: moving to a new house, getting a new job, maybe your computer dies…
If you follow my blog and usually keep up with our weekly writer coaching sessions, you've probably noticed I haven't been posting for a few weeks. (In fact, I’ve had to republish all my previous posts, including this one.) That’s because my computer decided to die on me. I was right in the middle of creating a webinar for you guys, when the computer crashed and decided not to turn back on. It was in the hospital for a while, and I thought I had the issue resolved but ended up having to replace it. So, yes, sometimes technology forces you to take a break.
You may also be experiencing extreme stress from some other area of life. That can kill inspiration and creativity…fast. Maybe you have a job besides writing, and something going on with that job is creating stress. Even changing jobs can cause stress. You may have some kind of family situation, financial issues, etc. Extreme stress can make it hard to be inspired, so you may need to take a break and relax and try to resolve whatever the issue is that's causing the stress.
You may also be experiencing burnout. If you have lots of demands on your time besides your writing, and you've been working nonstop, writing, taking care of your family, and all the things, you may just be tired and need a break. When was the last time you took a vacation and just really didn't do anything? If you're not sure of the answer to that question, this may be the cause.
I do want to offer caution, though. If you decide to take a break for any of these reasons or something I haven't listed here, make sure the break isn't too long. The longer you're away, the harder it is to get back into writing.
While you're on the break, if you can, try to refill your creative well. Read other people's books, watch movies, do something else creative that relaxes you. Maybe you like playing video games, and that is your downtime. If you can, during your break, do some of these things just to recharge. And above all, get some rest if possible.
2. Stop Writing Your Current Story
Sometimes, we may feel like we need to stop working on a particular project or abandon the current story we're writing.
Why you may feel the need to abandon a story
If this is worse than normal writer's block, you feel stuck, and you really don't know how to move forward, you may feel like giving up on the project. Maybe you've painted yourself into such a big corner that there's no way you can figure out for your characters to get out of this situation.
Or maybe you've received quite a bit of negative feedback on your book from people that you're having read it, or from publishers to whom you've submitted this story. Maybe you're sharing scenes in your writer's group, you keep getting negative feedback, and you're really discouraged.
You could be feeling like you've lost faith in this story or in yourself as a writer.
And maybe you just don't enjoy the story anymore or even have come to loathe writing it. That's not good!
Why you shouldn't abandon your story
Let's discuss some reasons why you may not want to abandon that story, and what to do instead.
If what you're dealing with is just a form of writer's block, you can overcome this. Remember those tips I gave you earlier? Some of those may work, or get some outside help from another writer. A writing coach or freelance editor could also give you some assistance on this. Either way, try to get another set of eyes on your project. That can often be the catalyst we need to write ourselves out of a tough spot.
Try to go ahead and finish the story. Even if you know something Is broken and you're not sure how to fix it, just write around it. Finishing the story can help you figure out what else needs to happen. Now that you know more details about the ending or what happens next, it may help you to fix this part that was broken.
Even if you're not sure how to fix the story right after you've finished it, you may, after writing several more books, be able to go back to this original one and figure out how to make it better. Once you've learned more about the writing craft, you may be able to diagnose the problem and end up releasing this one later in your career.
Writing a story all the way through gives you valuable experience in how to complete a story. It forces you to go through all the story beats, from the inciting incident all the way through the climax and resolution. That is valuable experience and helps you learn more about how to craft stories, or perhaps how not to.
Why am I encouraging you so strongly to not abandon your story, but to finish it? Well, you don't want to get into the habit of not finishing stories, especially as a newer writer. It can be dangerous to start and stop lots of stories and never get any farther than early in the project.
We can fall prey to “shiny object syndrome.” Usually, it's the middle of the story that trips people up. We get to that part, and we're not so excited anymore. When we have a brand new story idea, we can't wait to dive into that. But after we've been there for a while, maybe the writing gets a little harder. We've gotten through the exciting beginning of the story, and now we're moving into the middle, and it's a lot more work. Of course, we might have great ideas for the end of the book, and we're excited about that, but getting there seems too far away. Then, we have a new idea, and we think, " Ooh, squirrel!" and we want to move on to that one.
This can be really dangerous. For one thing, you don't learn all you need to about writing those middle pieces of the story. The only way to get better as a writer is to practice. So, I encourage you, if you're just starting out, especially, try to finish that first book.
If you look at the statistics of how many people think they want to write a book, the number drops significantly when we look at how many people actually start a book. After that, the number of people who start a book and finish it drops drastically. So, if you finish a novel, whether it's good or not, you've done something that most people who think they want be writers have never done. That should improve your confidence in your future as a writer. You have just accomplished a rare thing, and it's something to be proud of!
When SHOULD You abandon the story?
However, there are instances in which you maybe should abandon a story. Let's look at those.
Maybe you have come to absolutely hate this story and have no desire to work on it anymore. That can be a real thing. But I want to caution you. Every writer I've asked about this says this happens to them at some point during every project they work on.
You may not absolutely hate it, but you really don't like the story right now. This can happen during the writing or after you've finished the book, but at some point, you've been working on it so long or working so hard on it, you just don't even like the story anymore. Or you think it's terrible. Maybe the story in your head is so much more fun than the one that ended up on the page. That doesn't mean it's going to stay that way.
Give yourself time. See if that dislike of your story wears off. Take a break from the project. Do something else. When you come back to it and reread what you've written, chances are you won’t hate it so much. Better yet, give it to a friend to read and let them know you're not looking for advice on this story. You just need to know whether they enjoyed it. Ask what they did like about it. Most of the time, you'll rediscover what was fun about writing this in the first place.
However, if this persists—you have no connection to the characters anymore, you don't even like these people, you're tired of the plot—and you just don't want to write it anymore, then maybe you shouldn't, or at least not right now. Stick it in a drawer. Don't delete the file. Put it away somewhere in a folder and save it for later. You might come back to it at some point and decide to resurrect it, or you may not, and that's okay. It doesn't mean you've failed as a writer. It's just not the story for you.
You may want to abandon the story if you've written several different drafts, and I'm not talking about minor revisions. We're talking about rewrites, here. If you've tried that several times, and it's still not better, this idea just may not work as a story.
Also, perhaps you've completed several books or stories and have begun to be able to tell what works and what doesn't, or when something's fundamentally broken in a story. If that's the case, and you can tell that something serious is broken at the core of this story, you may need to abandon it. Maybe extract some of the ideas and use them in a different project.
3. Stop Being a Writer
Now, let's tackle the big question. Is there ever a time you should stop being a writer, altogether?
Why you may feel the need to stop being a writer
There are two huge contributors to the feeling that you really aren't cut out to be a writer.
Comparison-itis: This occurs when you’re comparing your writing or the stage you’ve reached in your career to that of other authors. Maybe a friend who started writing at the same time you did is much farther along in the process than you are (or even just got published). Perhaps you've been writing longer than this person has, and they have already “made it” or finished their book. You could also be comparing yourself to one of your favorite authors, and you're thinking, " I just don't have what it takes."
Imposter syndrome: This happens when we feel like we are not adequate or as good as other people. Now, this is very similar to comparison-itis, but here we focused on our own inadequacies rather than how we stack up to other people. We may feel like we don't know enough, don't have the necessary talent or skills, or can never learn all that is necessary to be good at this craft. We feel like people are going to figure out that we're not any good at writing. If we submit a book to publishers, or if we self-publish and people read it, they're going to realize we're just lousy writers. That's a terrible way to feel, and we'll talk about solutions to that in a moment.
Maybe you feel like you need to stop being a writer because you're finding learning all the aspects of the writing craft overwhelming, confusing, or just too hard. You feel like you'll never master the techniques, grammar rules, etc.
Perhaps you feel the need to stop pursuing writing because you have such a busy schedule (a family, another job, etc.) and don’t think you’ll ever have time to be a writer.
Maybe you've received too much negative feedback, either from readers or your writers’ group, or rejections from publishers and agents.
Perhaps you are being subjected to external pressures to do something else with your life. Often, well-meaning friends and family will say things like, “You wanna be a writer? There's no money in writing,” or “There's no way you're going to make it. Don’t you know, it's a one-in-a-million shot for how many people get published?” Or maybe family members want you to follow some other career path.
Or perhaps you've discovered that you don't really enjoy writing as much as you thought you would. It seemed a lot more fun or sounded a lot more elegant and exciting than the reality is.
Why you shouldn't stop being a writer
Well, let's look at all the reasons why you might not want to stop being a writer and what to do about these feelings you're having.
First, let's tackle comparison-itis and imposter syndrome. We can't compare ourselves to anyone else. We shouldn't, anyway. We do. It's our human nature, for some reason. I guess competition is wired into our DNA to a certain extent.
However, consider the people to whom you're comparing yourself. Are they experienced authors? Published? Maybe even bestsellers? You can't compare yourself to them if you’re just starting out, because they have much more experience than you do. You also don't know when they started writing. It may seem that an author just came out of nowhere and got the first book they ever wrote published. That does happen on occasion, but not often. Usually, people have to write several novels before they write one well enough to get it published. Or if they're self-publishing, it takes a while and lots of practice before they write a book that is well-received by an audience and picks up a lot of readers.
We also shouldn't compare ourselves to our writer friends. I had an experience that could have placed me in danger of this. When I released my debut novel, Keeper of Shadows, my friend Sharon also released her first novel. Since then, she has gone on to publish a number of books more than I have. But she's retired and writes full-time, whereas I've been posting to this blog, releasing YouTube videos weekly, teaching creative writing classes, and editing for clients. Our life situations are completely different. I'm super excited for her and thrilled that she has so many books out, but there are times when I feel like I'm a slacker. However, coaching writers and editing are also part of what I enjoy about the craft. Helping other people realize their writing dreams gives me almost as much fulfillment as writing my own books. So, it's a tradeoff.
Also keep in mind, if you're comparing yourself to someone who's at a similar stage as where you are, you don't know how long that person's been writing. One reason my friend has published so many books is because she had partially written some of them years ago.
As far as imposter syndrome goes, just know that everybody experiences this—well, I'd say 95% of the population—regardless of what field people are in or how much experience they have.
I once attended a writer's conference in which a bestselling author said he still experiences imposter syndrome. He struggles with thoughts like: "One of these days, they're gonna figure out that all these books I've written really aren't any good, and I'm lousy at this." If someone of that caliber still experiences imposter syndrome, how much more can we as newer writers or beginning writers?
If you start feeling this way, just remember that attorneys, doctors, educators, and even your editor, feels this. Yep, that's right. I experience imposter syndrome even as an editor. Try to shove those thoughts aside and move on. Don't give them any more weight than they deserve (which is zero).
If you're overwhelmed and feeling like you'll never learn all the aspects of writing craft, choose one area in which you know you need to improve. Focus on that one thing, master it, and then move to the next. Don't try to do it all at once. Most of us can't handle that. And find a good writing coach or a good writer's group that can help you through some of this. And remember, you don't have to know everything. Even bestselling books…sometimes especially bestselling books…still have mistakes in them or could be improved.
Writing is both an art and a craft. The art asks, “Can you tell a good story? Do you come up with interesting ideas?” That, you're born with. The craft part—the skill to bring those ideas to the page and make them impact readers—that can be learned. Just be patient with yourself. You'll get this!
If you've been receiving negative feedback or perhaps lots of rejection letters from publishers, again I advise practice. The more you write, the better you'll be at it. And keep in mind that many highly successful, bestselling authors receive lots of rejections from publishers before they make it.
One bestselling author who writes for teens, Brian Davis, is famous for carrying around a folder full of more than 200 rejection letters that he received before he got his first book published. He brings those rejection letters to workshops to encourage other writers. He even received some that said, “There's no market for your stories.” And this was back before self-publishing was really a viable part of the industry. He didn't give up. You shouldn't either!
Even the author of Harry Potter, J. K. Rowling, received rejections—I think it was twelve rejections—from publishers before one decided to pick it up. Imagine how much those other twelve publishers are kicking themselves for rejecting that multimillion dollar bestselling series.
As writers, we need to develop a thick skin. Jerry B. Jenkins, one of the authors of the Left Behindseries, likes to talk about this, the thick-skinned writer. We can't be too sensitive to negative feedback. It's going to happen, not just before you're published, but even after. Negative reviews, anyone? So, we must not let it destroy our creativity or desire to be a writer. Just know it's going to happen and try to take it in a constructive way. Often, constructive feedback, especially if it's from your writer's group, is intended to help you. So, instead of becoming defensive or feeling defeated, consider it a learning opportunity.
If you're still feeling like you shouldn't be a writer, you're not a good writer, or you'll never succeed at this, ask yourself one question: Why did you start writing in the first place? Maybe you wanted to write the kind of story you've been longing to read. Maybe you want to share a message with the world, or you've had this story idea burning in your head for a long time and you just need to get it out there. Maybe you actually wanted a career as an author.
Whatever the reason, your answer to this question could help you resolve the debate about whether you should still be a writer or not. Does the answer to this question still apply? If so, don't stop being a writer. Just take a break, regroup, and recharge.
When should you stop being a writer?
There are just a few times in which a person maybe should stop trying to be a writer. Let's look at what those might be.
Perhaps you've discovered you really don't enjoy writing like you thought you would. Every time you sit down to write, no matter what the project is, you just don't want to. You feel this dread, or it feels too much like work, or it's just not fun anymore. Maybe, it never was. You thought it would be, but it just isn't. Then, maybe you would enjoy some other creative pursuit more, and that's okay. After all, writing is not easy. You have to love it to stick with it
.
Perhaps you've discovered that you enjoy some other part of the publishing process more than writing. Maybe you're artistic, and you find that cover design really lights you up. Or maybe, like me, you enjoy editing. Perhaps you should check into that aspect of publishing instead. Perhaps you're fantastic at marketing. (😉 If so, give me a call. I could use your expertise.)
And finally, if you genuinely have no desire to put in the work that's required to become a better writer, maybe this isn't for you. Now, I don't mean that you feel overwhelmed for the moment. If you're just starting to feel that way, or if you just don't think you can learn this, at least try for a while and see if you can find a way that works for you. It's not easy. It takes effort, but anything worthwhile does. Most of us can't just pick up a musical instrument, for example, and play like Mozart. So, keep that in mind.
NOTE: If you fall into any of these three scenarios and discover that you should stop writing for a while, or abandon your book, or stop being a writer, altogether, this does not make you a failure as a person. Just consider it a learning experience and move on. Either take your break and get back to writing, or if you're abandoning a particular project, get right into the next one. And if you decided not to be a writer at all, then find something else you will love and pursue that.
This Week's Power-Up
To help you diagnose whether your inclination to stop writing is an indication that you just need to take a break, or should abandon your story, or should stop writing altogether, here are a few questions you can ask yourself:
And if you're dealing with a life event that has derailed your writing for a while, for more tips on how to keep writing when life gets in the way, check out this post.
Make Your Story Powerful!
Watch my FREE 25-minute video workshop to learn the 6 elements every story needs so readers will experience the characters' journey with maximum emotional impact.
You'll also receive weekly writing tips and training via email. We'll never send spam. Unsubscribe at any time
© 2023 B Squared Writer Coaching