Let's Power Up Your Storytelling!

ChatGPT, An Author's Best Friend or Biggest Threat?

Hey, storyteller!


Will the latest mind-blowing artificial intelligence tools supercharge your writing process and output…or replace you?


If you've been surfing the internet or browsing YouTube in the past few months, you've probably seen a lot of hype and fears surrounding ChatGPT and other artificial intelligence tools designed to answer questions, provide detailed information, and even write for you.


A number of videos have been released demonstrating how to use these tools to write everything from blog posts to entire books, uses which raise questions about ethics related to creativity and intellectual property, not to mention whether these tools will take over the writing industry and render human authors obsolete.


This leaves writers with one overarching question: Is AI your best friend or biggest threat?


In this week's writer coaching session, we'll discuss what ChatGPT is and how it can help you write and market your books faster and more effectively, cautions to keep in mind when using it, and how to tackle the ethical considerations surrounding AI and creativity.


You will discover:

  • what ChatGPT is and how to access it
  • cautions, flaws, and ethical consideration authors should keep in mind when using ChatGPT
  • ways in which authors should NOT use AI tools
  • how ChatGPT can help you brainstorm, research, outline, write, and even market your story

Will AI Replace Authors?

Before we dive into other aspects of this topic, I want to begin with a note of hope. I do not believe artificial intelligence tools will remove the need or readers’ desire for human authors.


Will it change or even disrupt the publishing industry in some ways? That's a near certainty. But then, so did eBooks! And they made self-publishing a more viable path for authors, giving readers more books to choose from.


Your greatest asset to storytelling is your own creativity and understanding of what makes a story resonate with readers. That is irreplaceable!

I Have a Gift for You!

One aspect of storytelling that we human authors know must never seem artificial is our characters. To help you keep your characters as human as possible, I want to give you my R.E.A.L. Method to Creating Unforgettable Characters. This free PDF will help you make every character in your story three-dimensional and memorable in four easy to follow steps, no AI required.


And be sure to read to the end of this post, so you won't miss this week's Power-Up, a super practical action step you can take while working on your story, right now.

The Perks of Using AI Tools

Have you ever wished you could have a brainstorming buddy, research assistant, plotting coach, or marketing copywriter at your beck and call, day or night? Well, now you can. Sort of.


Writing a novel or book-length memoir can be a daunting task, and sometimes we need a little help to get past that blank page or get out of the corner we've written ourselves into. That's where ChatGPT and similar AI tools can come in handy.


Nothing can replace our human brainstorming buddies, critique partners, or writer’s group members, but let's face it, people have different schedules. Whether your favorite brainstorming partner has a day job or needs to sleep when you're awake, they're not always available at the moment when we need help.


Artificial intelligence tools don't need to sleep, and they can provide guidance, idea generation, and support whenever and wherever you need them…as long as you have an internet connection, of course. Since, at the moment, ChatGPT is the most popular and probably the most well-developed tool out there, I’ll focus on it throughout this post.


Keep in mind that the development of AI is moving super fast right now. So, if you're reading this sometime in the future, things may have changed. Other tools may have been developed that are more streamlined or even more effective. And the caveats I'm going to share about ChatGPT may no longer be relevant, because these tools are always improving.

What Is ChatGPT?

Just in case you're not familiar with it, ChatGPT is an artificial intelligence (AI) chat bot developed by OpenAI and released in November 2022. Think of it like a text messaging app or the chat feature on a website, where you can interact with a company's customer support team.


The user types in a prompt (message) that either asks a question or provides information as context and requests an action. This prompt is written in human-like language. So, you write it as if you were texting with a friend.


ChatGPT responds in a conversational style, and it can recall and build on all the information that has come before in that particular conversation. Now, if you start a different chat (a different conversation), the AI will have no idea what went on in the previous conversation. It's like you've started chatting with a completely different robot.


The good thing is, no programming is necessary. This conversational style of input and output makes ChatGPT and similar artificial intelligence tools much easier for us to use. That, I think, is what makes them so revolutionary.


However, ChatGPT and similar large language models, as they're called, do have their flaws—inconsistent factual, accuracy, chief among them.

Cautions When Using ChatGPT

First, I want to point out that I do not advocate having ChatGPT write your entire story for you. That's neither ethical nor in keeping with a writer's desire for creativity.


After all, you’re a writer because you want to tell the stories that are inside your head, not because you are longing to press a button and have a machine generate stories for you. We'll get into more of that and the ethical considerations a bit later in the post.


For a fun experiment, I used ChatGPT to help me create certain sections of the outline for this post. One of the questions I asked it was to list precautions we writers should keep in mind when using it. I know, it's a little meta, right? Asking it for warnings about itself. Here's what it gave me:


CAUTION 1: “ChatGPT is a machine learning model and does not have emotions or a moral compass. While it can provide information on a wide range of topics, it may not always provide answers that are sensitive to human emotion or moral considerations.”


CAUTION 2: “ChatGPT can only generate responses based on the data it has been trained on. As a result, it may provide inaccurate or incomplete information, especially on complex or niche topics that it may not have been trained on.”


This is the big one. It isn't always accurate.


According to my research, it was trained on a lot of data from the internet and quite a few books. But GPT 3.5—and, I believe, GPT 4—received training only on data up to the year 202. Now, GPT 4 is reported to have the potential for live internet access, when used in certain plugins. And if you're watching this in the future, whatever models are out there may have expanded or completely different parameters.


CAUTION 3: “ChatGPT's responses are generated based on statistical patterns found in its training data. As such, it may sometimes generate responses that are irrelevant, nonsensical, or even offensive.”


Here is a comforting one:


CAUTION 4: “ChatGPT is not a replacement for human expertise or critical thinking.” (I would add creativity, here.) “Writers should use ChatGPT's responses as a starting point for their own research and writing, and should verify the accuracy of any information they receive.”


CAUTION 5: “ChatGPT may sometimes generate responses that are biased or reflect the biases present in its training data. It's important for writers to be aware of this and to critically evaluate any information they receive from ChatGPT.”


One of the biggest criticisms from a number of people about ChatGPT is that it seems to have been programmed to be politically correct or perhaps even carry some left-leaning political views.

Ethical Use of AI Tools for Authors

Another huge criticism of artificial intelligence tools—especially image generation tools like Midjourney, Stable Diffusion, and DALL-E—is the question of copyright and ethical use of what has been created. These same concerns apply to text generation tools like ChatGPT.


One major issue surrounding image generation tools is that they are being trained on images and artwork that's created by humans…without those people's consent or permission. Thus, the original artist or photographer is not compensated for the use of his or her artwork.


With that in mind, should we use text generated by a chatbot in our writing? Since these language models are trained on data from the internet, we don't want to have it generate a blog post, for example, and later discover that part or all of it has been plagiarized from someone else's article.


The Alliance of Independent Authors (ALLI) has posted an article titled “AI for Authors: Practical and Ethical Guidelines.” The screenshot below shows the sections that I think are most pertinent to us right now.

Alliance of Independent Authors: Ethical Guidelines for Using AI Tools

One of the most crucial pieces of advice in this article is to never copy and paste AI-generated text directly into your manuscript and publish it as-is. You'll want to edit the text to make it fit your writing voice, style, and story using writing craft techniques and principles of good storytelling.


Often, the text generated by ChatGPT and other language models is pretty basic, cliche, and amateur storytelling at best. Plus, it's not written in your voice. And we all know how important writer's voice is to establishing an individual identity as a storyteller.


ALLI’s guidelines also suggest that we include an “AI statement of usage” in our books, stating which tools we've used in the process of creating the finished work. Bestselling independently published author Joanna Penn talks about this statement of usage in a video she released on how to use Sudowrite, an AI application designed for authors. YouTuber Author Level Up also has a playlist of videos on the use of AI for authors.

AI-Generated Books

One of my biggest concerns is that people who aren't writers will try to game the system and self-publish books that are completely generated by AI, flooding the marketplace with poor quality books.


But let's face it, that's already happening. Some people who self-publish produce books without anyediting. Keep in mind, I am saying some, because many self-published books are just as fantastic as those that are traditionally published. So, please don't take that out of context. Yes, there will be people who use AI in this manner, but I don't think those books will sell well—at least for very long—because readers can tell the difference, and reviews will reflect that.


The possibility of AI-generated books again raised the question of whether AI is going to replace authors, I really think the biggest challenge we'll face in pretty much any industry is the need to compete with people who are using these AI tools to enhance their productivity and accelerate their workflow, rather than the AI tools themselves.


Right now, at least, these tools don't do anything without human prompting or humans requesting an action. They're not going out there and writing stories on their own!


The general advice across industries is that we learn the skills necessary to use these tools and workwith them, rather than fearing them.

How to Access ChatGPT

First, go to chat.openai.com. If this is your first time, you'll need to set up a free account with OpenAI. You'll have the option of choosing an easy login with a Google, Apple, or Microsoft account or just inserting your email address and creating a password.


Next, you'll be asked to enter a phone number. OpenAI needs this to send you a verification code to make sure, ironically, that you are not a robot. You'll enter that code on the registration page to complete the setup.

Then, you'll see some housekeeping rules about ChatGPT, including potential errors in data, how OpenAI collects data, and how users can submit feedback. There are a couple screens, so just keep clicking Next to cycle through them.

Once you do that, it'll bring you to this screen, where you’ll find the prompt bar at the bottom.

ChatGPT Tips for Authors

So, how can you use this tool to enhance your process as a writer?


I'm will give you an overview of these tips, but several YouTubers have released full demonstrations of their processes for using AI as writers. The Nerdy Novelist, for example, has posted an entire seriesin which he walks through the entire process of creating a book with ChatGPT, from idea generation to writing the actual text.

Brainstorming with ChatGPT

The first task with which ChatGPT can be super helpful is the brainstorming process.


One of the most enjoyable, yet challenging aspects of writing a novel is coming up with fresh ideas.


Brainstorming with a friend, fellow writer, or writer's group is a fun way to defeat the dreaded blank page, but those human helpers aren't always available the moment we need them. ChatGPT can fill in the gap during a late-night writing session, or when your plotting partners are busy.

Simply type in a prompt, and it will spit out a list of potential plot points, character traits, setting details, or whatever other story element you request.


It can also help you generate new ideas for storylines. For example, if you're stuck on a particular scene, you can ask ChatGPT for suggestions on how to move the story forward. You would need to give it some context, of course, for what has come before in the story.


If you're struggling with character development, you can provide ChatGPT with a brief description of your character and ask for ideas on how to make him or her more complex and interesting.


ChatGPT can also ask you questions to jumpstart your own flow of ideas. For example, I prompted ChatGPT with: "I'd like to write a science fiction novel about an author who teens up with an AI to write a bestseller. Please ask me some questions to help me get started."

ChatGPT responded with: "Sure, I'll be happy to help you get started on your science fiction novel. Here are a few questions to help you think about your story." (In the beginning of a response, ChatGPT will often rephrase part of your question. I think it does this in order to make sure it has understood your request.)


It listed a number of useful questions, then ended with the polite statement, " I hope these questions help you get started on your story."

Researching with ChatGPT

The next aspect of writing in which ChatGPT claims to be extremely useful is research. I don't know about you, but I would love some help with this part of the process. It can be time-consuming and overwhelming.


ChatGPT claims it can streamline your research process. While it can certainly help, always double check the information it provides, because remember, it's not always accurate.


Unlike a search engine, ChatGPT won't just give you links to articles and websites you'll have to comb through. It can summarize relevant articles, studies, and expert opinions on your topic. For example, if your novel is set during the Civil War, it can give you information on battles, key figures, and daily life during that time period. Again, the problem is accuracy.


ChatGPT claims it can help you fact check your novel. For example, if you're writing historical fiction and are unsure whether a particular detail is accurate, ChatGPT says you could ask it to verify the information. This could save you time and ensure that the novel is as accurate and authentic as possible."


However, I suggest saving its responses in a file and making a note to yourself to fact check any information it provides. You can ask it for the source of the information it has provided, but keep in mind that it has been known to list the names and authors of books that don't actually exist.


As an experiment, I prompted ChatGPT with, " I'm writing a novel set in medieval Europe. Can you provide information on the daily life of peasants during that time?"

ChatGPT responded with information about work and daily tasks, housing, clothing, food, health and hygiene, religion, and entertainment. Its categorization of all this information—without even being asked to do so—could be very helpful for compiling your world-building notes.


To make this prompt more targeted, you could list the specific details you need. However, this more open-ended prompt does allow the AI to suggest topics you might not have considered.

Plotting & Outlining with ChatGPT

Artificial intelligence can help with the plotting and outlining stage of writing a book, whether you're a plotter or a discovery writer who uses an outline as part of the revision process.


It can provide a template for you to follow, including plot points, character arcs, and themes, or you can input your own story structure. For example, you could ask it to give you plot ideas based on the Hero's Journey framework or on the story beats laid out in Blake Snyder's book Save the Cat.


I suggest first asking ChatGPT whether it's familiar with the framework you want to use and to outline that framework, so you can make corrections if needed. Then, ask it to generate your plot ideas based on that framework.


If you'd like to use a story structure or framework with which ChatGPT is not familiar—for example, my list of seven essential story beats—you will need to paste that in as part of your prompt to give it context, with brief explanations for each section of the story structure.


ChatGPT can also help you refine and revise your story's plot outline or chapter-by-chapter breakdown. For example, if you're having trouble with the pacing of your novel, you can paste in the outline you’ve written so far and ask ChatGPT for suggestions on how to structure your plot points to keep the story moving forward or speed it up a bit.


ChatGPT can also provide writing prompts and exercises to help you stay inspired and motivated throughout the writing process, or combat some causes of writer's block.


You can ask it for ideas on how to develop a particular character, create a compelling opening scene, or tackle a tricky plot point. Just remember to be specific, provide context, and keep refining your prompt or asking for more detail until you receive the help you're looking for.


The first prompt you provide isn't always going to give you what you need, so you can keep embellishing. For example, asking ChatGPT to add more emotion to what it has written, or perhaps deepen the internal conflict, provide more setting detail, use deep point of view, show don't tell, that sort of thing.

Marketing with ChatGPT

Marketing is one area that gives authors significant difficulty, myself included. It can seem harder to write a book description for the back cover or a synopsis for editors and agents than it has been to write the entire book! ChatGPT can help you craft compelling and concise marketing language to draw readers in.


For example, you could provide a brief summary of your novel, and it can create a back cover book description that highlights the most exciting and intriguing aspects of your story. Be specific in your prompt, asking it to craft a description that raises curiosity and intrigue and makes readers excited to buy the book.


ChatGPT claims it can also help you write query letters to literary agents, taglines, or a full synopsis. It says, “You can provide ChatGPT with a brief summary of your novel, and it can help you craft a compelling pitch that will catch the attention of potential readers or agents.”


If you do use it to help you write a query letter or synopsis, I strongly advise you to edit the text thoroughly. Do not submit it as-is to an agent or publisher.


Can ChatGPT really help you write a full book synopsis? Yes and no. We can input only a limited number of characters in a single prompt, so you can't just paste an entire novel into ChatGPT and ask it for a one-page synopsis…yet. It is best to provide a brief summary of the story’s main plot points, characters, relationships, and themes. A good guideline is to keep the prompt between 200 and 400 words. I have been told that the more characters you use in your input, the more likely ChatGPT is to produce less accurate or less useful outputs.

Editing with ChatGPT

One aspect of the writing process with which many authors would love to have help is editing. Can AI assist you here? Yes and no.


Once you've completed your first draft, ChatGPT claims it can also help you edit and revise your manuscript. It says you can ask it for suggestions on how to improve your prose, eliminate redundancies, and tighten your plot.


Well, let's look at the plot part, for example. You'd have to paste in your entire outline for it to help you with this. That might be a bit tricky.


ChatGPT also gives this caveat, with which I strongly agree with (and you won't be surprised). "Keep in mind that ChatGPT is an AI language model and may not always provide the most accurate or nuanced feedback.”


If you do want to use a tool to help with the editing process, I recommend something like Grammarly or ProWritingAid. Yes, they do use artificial intelligence as well, but it’s more targeted and—reportedly—more accurate. Though these tools have a more proven track record, they produce inaccuracies as well, so just be careful.


None of them would be a true replacement for the experience of a human editor or the genuine feedback that you would receive from beta readers.


You could use these tools to help with some basic proofreading and copy editing. That might make your editor's job a little easier, but don't use them by themselves as your only editor, Human editors and beta readers can, for instance, tell you if your character is being inconsistent, seems flat, or strays from his/her character voice in a certain section of the story.

This Week's Power-Up

If you are interested in experimenting with ChatGPT and seeing whether it can streamline or supercharge your writing process, I suggest signing up and practicing with a few prompts.


Keep in mind that you may need to give the AI more direction or information if it didn't provide enough detail or if its response is rather basic or generic. You can ask it to expand on the information, explain in more detail, include information it has left out (like character conflict, emotional stakes, etc.)


Feel free to check out any of the demonstration videos linked in this post (and listed below). And for more resources on plotting, world-building, the writing process, and other aspects of writing and editing your book, check out this post, in which I list eight writing craft book recommendations.

And let's power up your storytelling!

Related Posts

Helpful LInks

Make Your Story Powerful!

Watch my FREE 25-minute video workshop to learn the 6 elements every story needs so readers will experience the characters' journey with maximum emotional impact.

You'll also receive weekly writing tips and training via email. We'll never send spam. Unsubscribe at any time


© 2023 B Squared Writer Coaching